General strategies to increase the repeatability in non-target screening by liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry

Tobias Bader, Wolfgang Schulz, Klaus Kümmerer, Rudi Winzenbacher

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article focuses on the data evaluation of non-target high-resolution LC-MS profiles of water samples. Taking into account multiple technical replicates, the difficulties in peak recognition and the related problems of false positive and false negative findings are systematically demonstrated. On the basis of a combinatorial approach, different models involving sophisticated workflows are evaluated, particularly with regard to the repeatability. In addition, the improvement resulting from data processing was systematically taken into consideration where the recovery of spiked standards emphasized that real peaks of interest were barely or not removed by the derived filter criteria. The comprehensive evaluation included different matrix types spiked with up to 263 analytical standards which were analyzed repeatedly leading to a total number of more than 250 injections that were incorporated in the assessment of different models of data processing. It was found that the analysis of multiple replicates is the key factor as, on the one hand, it provides the option of integrating valuable filters in order to minimize the false positive rate and, on the other hand, allows correcting partially false negative findings occurring during the peak recognition. The developed processing strategies including replicates clearly point to an enhanced data quality since both the repeatability as well as the peak recognition could be considerably improved. As proof of concept, four different matrix types, including a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent, were spiked with 130 isotopically labeled standards at different concentration levels. Despite the stringent filter criteria, at 100 ng L−1 recovery rates of up to 93% were reached in the positive ionization mode. The proposed model, comprising three technical replicates, filters less than 5% and 2% of the standards recognized at 100 and 500 ng L−1, respectively and thus indicates the general applicability of the presented strategies.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)173-186
Number of pages14
JournalAnalytica Chimica Acta
Volume935
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Fingerprint

Liquid chromatography
Liquid Chromatography
Mass spectrometry
liquid chromatography
Mass Spectrometry
Screening
mass spectrometry
filter
Recovery
matrix
Workflow
Waste Water
data quality
Wastewater treatment
Ionization
Effluents
ionization
effluent
Injections
screening

Cite this

@article{cc409298c439444eb29e090c1c0b63a1,
title = "General strategies to increase the repeatability in non-target screening by liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry",
abstract = "This article focuses on the data evaluation of non-target high-resolution LC-MS profiles of water samples. Taking into account multiple technical replicates, the difficulties in peak recognition and the related problems of false positive and false negative findings are systematically demonstrated. On the basis of a combinatorial approach, different models involving sophisticated workflows are evaluated, particularly with regard to the repeatability. In addition, the improvement resulting from data processing was systematically taken into consideration where the recovery of spiked standards emphasized that real peaks of interest were barely or not removed by the derived filter criteria. The comprehensive evaluation included different matrix types spiked with up to 263 analytical standards which were analyzed repeatedly leading to a total number of more than 250 injections that were incorporated in the assessment of different models of data processing. It was found that the analysis of multiple replicates is the key factor as, on the one hand, it provides the option of integrating valuable filters in order to minimize the false positive rate and, on the other hand, allows correcting partially false negative findings occurring during the peak recognition. The developed processing strategies including replicates clearly point to an enhanced data quality since both the repeatability as well as the peak recognition could be considerably improved. As proof of concept, four different matrix types, including a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent, were spiked with 130 isotopically labeled standards at different concentration levels. Despite the stringent filter criteria, at 100 ng L−1 recovery rates of up to 93{\%} were reached in the positive ionization mode. The proposed model, comprising three technical replicates, filters less than 5{\%} and 2{\%} of the standards recognized at 100 and 500 ng L−1, respectively and thus indicates the general applicability of the presented strategies.",
author = "Tobias Bader and Wolfgang Schulz and Klaus K{\"u}mmerer and Rudi Winzenbacher",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1016/j.aca.2016.06.030",
language = "English",
volume = "935",
pages = "173--186",
journal = "Analytica Chimica Acta",
issn = "0003-2670",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

General strategies to increase the repeatability in non-target screening by liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry. / Bader, Tobias; Schulz, Wolfgang; Kümmerer, Klaus; Winzenbacher, Rudi.

In: Analytica Chimica Acta, Vol. 935, 2016, p. 173-186.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - General strategies to increase the repeatability in non-target screening by liquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry

AU - Bader, Tobias

AU - Schulz, Wolfgang

AU - Kümmerer, Klaus

AU - Winzenbacher, Rudi

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - This article focuses on the data evaluation of non-target high-resolution LC-MS profiles of water samples. Taking into account multiple technical replicates, the difficulties in peak recognition and the related problems of false positive and false negative findings are systematically demonstrated. On the basis of a combinatorial approach, different models involving sophisticated workflows are evaluated, particularly with regard to the repeatability. In addition, the improvement resulting from data processing was systematically taken into consideration where the recovery of spiked standards emphasized that real peaks of interest were barely or not removed by the derived filter criteria. The comprehensive evaluation included different matrix types spiked with up to 263 analytical standards which were analyzed repeatedly leading to a total number of more than 250 injections that were incorporated in the assessment of different models of data processing. It was found that the analysis of multiple replicates is the key factor as, on the one hand, it provides the option of integrating valuable filters in order to minimize the false positive rate and, on the other hand, allows correcting partially false negative findings occurring during the peak recognition. The developed processing strategies including replicates clearly point to an enhanced data quality since both the repeatability as well as the peak recognition could be considerably improved. As proof of concept, four different matrix types, including a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent, were spiked with 130 isotopically labeled standards at different concentration levels. Despite the stringent filter criteria, at 100 ng L−1 recovery rates of up to 93% were reached in the positive ionization mode. The proposed model, comprising three technical replicates, filters less than 5% and 2% of the standards recognized at 100 and 500 ng L−1, respectively and thus indicates the general applicability of the presented strategies.

AB - This article focuses on the data evaluation of non-target high-resolution LC-MS profiles of water samples. Taking into account multiple technical replicates, the difficulties in peak recognition and the related problems of false positive and false negative findings are systematically demonstrated. On the basis of a combinatorial approach, different models involving sophisticated workflows are evaluated, particularly with regard to the repeatability. In addition, the improvement resulting from data processing was systematically taken into consideration where the recovery of spiked standards emphasized that real peaks of interest were barely or not removed by the derived filter criteria. The comprehensive evaluation included different matrix types spiked with up to 263 analytical standards which were analyzed repeatedly leading to a total number of more than 250 injections that were incorporated in the assessment of different models of data processing. It was found that the analysis of multiple replicates is the key factor as, on the one hand, it provides the option of integrating valuable filters in order to minimize the false positive rate and, on the other hand, allows correcting partially false negative findings occurring during the peak recognition. The developed processing strategies including replicates clearly point to an enhanced data quality since both the repeatability as well as the peak recognition could be considerably improved. As proof of concept, four different matrix types, including a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent, were spiked with 130 isotopically labeled standards at different concentration levels. Despite the stringent filter criteria, at 100 ng L−1 recovery rates of up to 93% were reached in the positive ionization mode. The proposed model, comprising three technical replicates, filters less than 5% and 2% of the standards recognized at 100 and 500 ng L−1, respectively and thus indicates the general applicability of the presented strategies.

U2 - 10.1016/j.aca.2016.06.030

DO - 10.1016/j.aca.2016.06.030

M3 - Article

VL - 935

SP - 173

EP - 186

JO - Analytica Chimica Acta

JF - Analytica Chimica Acta

SN - 0003-2670

ER -